HEISMAN 2025: FOUR WEEKS IN, THE RACE IS WIDE OPEN AND FASCINATING
Updated: 31 minutes ago
VANCOUVER, BC — Every fall, the month of September serves as a filter. It separates the early-season illusions from the serious Heisman candidacies. In just four weeks, several figures have already emerged: surgical quarterbacks, unstoppable running backs, a standout defender, and even an improbable tale lighting up the SEC. The first third of the season has already produced a cast as rich as it is varied.
Dante Moore (QB, Oregon): Surgical Precision
With 1,208 yards, 12 touchdowns, 1 interception, and a 74.6% completion rate, Moore is the metronome of the Ducks. His triumph in double overtime during the legendary “White Out” at Penn State displayed his composure. More than just stats, it’s his flawless execution that makes him a serious contender. If he continues to carry Oregon through a demanding Big Ten schedule, it will be difficult to knock him out of the top tier of the voting.
Ty Simpson (QB, Alabama): The Patient Heir
After three years in the shadows, Ty Simpson has finally taken control of the Crimson Tide. His numbers (987 yards, 11 TD, 0 INT) reflect rare efficiency. But his true signature moment came at Sanford Stadium last week, where he took down Georgia and ended the Bulldogs’ 33-game home winning streak. This Saturday in Tuscaloosa, he’ll face Diego Pavia in an SEC showdown that could tilt the Heisman race.
Diego Pavia (QB, Vanderbilt): The Engine of the Commodores’ Rise
Vanderbilt hadn’t started a season 5–0 since 2008. This resurgence has one name: Diego Pavia. With 1,211 passing yards, 9 touchdowns, 6 interceptions, plus 6 rushing scores, he brings a relentless energy that has transformed the Commodores’ identity. Just as capable of throwing a block for a runner as he is of breaking down a defense on his own, he has become the heartbeat of this team. A statement win in Tuscaloosa against Alabama on Saturday could elevate his candidacy from impressive to undeniable on the national stage.
Jonah Coleman (RB, Washington): The Bulldozer at Husky Stadium
His stat line took a hit in the loss to Ohio State, as the Buckeyes’ defense managed to smother Washington’s usually explosive attack. Even so, Coleman was one of the few Huskies to keep pushing, finishing runs with power and determination. With 10 total touchdowns (9 rushing, 1 receiving), he remains one of the most dominant running backs in the country. In Seattle, he has become the anchor of an offense in transition, and his constant battles against the Big Ten’s elite defenses give him the perfect stage to impress voters.
Ahmad Hardy (RB, Missouri): The Locomotive
The nation’s leading rusher with 730 yards and 9 touchdowns, Hardy steamrolls defenses at over 7 yards per carry.In an SEC where defenses usually set the tone, he has imposed rare power and consistency. Missouri has found its engine, and Hardy already looks like a credible finalist for New York.
John Mateer (QB, Oklahoma): On hold
Before his hand surgery, Mateer had already totaled 1,215 yards, 8 touchdowns, 3 interceptions, and more than 190 rushing yards. A transfer from Washington State, he quickly won over Norman with his energy and mobility. Now in recovery, he is expected to return in time for the Sooners’ crucial stretch against Alabama, Tennessee, and LSU. His health will not only determine whether his Heisman candidacy can be revived, it will directly shape the trajectory of Oklahoma’s program, still unbeaten but searching for national legitimacy.
Trinidad Chambliss (QB, Ole Miss): The Unexpected Star
Ole Miss has found its revelation in Trinidad Chambliss, a Division II transfer. Against LSU (No. 4), he threw for 314 yards, 1 TD, 1 INT, added 71 rushing yards, and delivered a 24–19 victory for the Rebels.Three straight 300-yard performances prove he is no flash in the pan. In the unforgiving SEC, he has emerged as a credible candidate, ready to shake up the hierarchy.
Rueben Bain Jr. (EDGE, Miami): The Defensive Uprising
With 22 tackles, 4 TFL, 2 sacks, and 1 interception, Bain Jr. is the engine of one of the country’s top defenses. Constantly double-teamed in opposing schemes, he frees up his teammates and terrorizes quarterbacks.Miami (No. 3) is back in the national spotlight, and Bain’s name is a big reason why. Defenders almost never win the Heisman, but Bain has already gone beyond “honorable mention” status: he is unavoidable.
Jayden Maiava (QB, USC): The Statistical Machine
With 1,587 yards, 17 TD, 1 INT, and a 70.5% completion rate, Maiava is simply the most productive quarterback in the country. His 191.1 rating tops all starters.The challenge will be proving he can sustain this pace against the rugged defenses of the Big Ten. But if USC keeps winning, it will be hard to leave him out of New York.
Conclusion: A Race Rich in Storylines
At this stage, no single candidacy clearly stands apart. Moore impresses with his consistency, Simpson embodies Alabama’s resurgence, Pavia electrifies all of Nashville, Coleman and Hardy carry their offenses, Mateer awaits his return, Chambliss surprises everyone, Bain Jr. breaks the mold, and Maiava piles up video-game numbers.
The Heisman is never just about statistics: it is won through storylines, signature moments, and the ability to shine when the lights are brightest. October and November will be unforgiving. But after one month of play, one certainty has already emerged: the 2025 crop promises to be one of the most open and fascinating of the last decade.
Comments